Boundary.lean
Proves that removing any pipeline stage leads to a measurable bad outcome — each stage is forced by the axioms, not optional. Each proof here is a formal instance of why
theory is load-bearing: the stages exist because the math demands them.
perceive_forced
The environment has strictly more distinguishable configurations than the system can represent internally. A lossy encoding step (Perceive) is forced to bridge the gap.
theorem perceive_forced (energy env_dim : Nat)
(henv : env_dim > energy)
: ∀ N : Nat, N ≤ energy → env_dim > N Derived from capacity_bound. If internal state could be as large as the environment, no lossy encoding would be needed.
no_cache_cumulative_loss
Without a buffer, rate mismatch causes cumulative loss. If input arrives faster than drain, at least one item is lost per cycle, and the loss compounds over time.
theorem no_cache_cumulative_loss
(input_rate drain_rate k : Nat)
(hmismatch : input_rate > drain_rate)
: k * (input_rate - drain_rate) ≥ k Derived from rate_mismatch. If input never exceeds drain rate, no buffer is needed.
cache_from_rate_mismatch
Cache existence follows directly from the rate_mismatch axiom: the axiom guarantees a scenario where input outpaces drain, and without a buffer, loss is cumulative.
no_filter_fills_store
Without selection, a store of finite capacity fills after enough insertions. Once full, the system halts or drops items implicitly. Explicit selection (Filter) prevents this.
theorem no_filter_fills_store
(capacity items_per_cycle : Nat) (hitems : items_per_cycle > 0)
: &exists; t : Nat, t * items_per_cycle ≥ capacity no_persistence_no_memory
Without persistence, a system with fixed state is a pure function of current input. Same input always produces same output regardless of history. This makes the system unable to handle history-dependent tasks.
Connections
- Axioms.lean — imported; every boundary proof cites an axiom
- Removal.lean — the full removal table, combining all boundary arguments
- Corollary.lean — derives the competitive core and control/data separation from these proofs